Investigative, respectful, and compulsively listenable — the true crime shows that set the standard for the genre.
True crime podcasting has matured. The best shows now balance compelling storytelling with ethical reporting and respect for victims.
These twelve shows are the ones worth listening to — and the ones worth studying if you are working in the genre.
How we chose these shows
Hosted by Sarah Koenig
The show that launched the true crime podcast boom. Season 1 remains a masterclass in investigative narrative.
Study Serial for how to withhold information ethically and structure an investigation as a story.
Hosted by Phoebe Judge
Crime stories told with empathy and restraint — focused on people, not spectacle.
Judge demonstrates the anti-sensationalist approach that builds trust with listeners over time.
Hosted by Anonymous host
Meticulously researched cases presented in a calm, anonymous narration style. No personality, pure story.
Casefile proves that a neutral host voice can be a feature, not a limitation, in true crime.
Hosted by Karen Kilgariff & Georgia Hardstark
Two comedians share murder stories with humour and advocacy. Built one of the largest true crime audiences.
MFAM shows how personality-driven true crime can work when the hosts earn trust through consistency and advocacy.
Hosted by Payne Lindsey
Payne Lindsey investigates cold cases in real time — with audience participation that actually moves cases forward.
Lindsey demonstrates how to involve an audience in an investigation without compromising journalistic standards.
Hosted by David Ridgen
CBC's investigative podcast — David Ridgen revisits cold cases with extraordinary persistence and care.
Ridgen shows what multi-season investigative commitment looks like when a journalist will not let go.
Hosted by Christopher Goffard
A Los Angeles Times investigation into a con man — adapted into podcast, TV, and film. Story first.
Dirty John shows how newspaper investigative reporting translates to narrative podcast format.
Hosted by Jason Moon
A New Hampshire cold case solved through podcast investigation — victims identified after decades.
Bear Brook is proof that podcast journalism can have real-world consequences. Ethical and relentless.
Hosted by Chris Lambert
An independent investigation into the disappearance of Kristin Smart. Helped lead to arrests.
Lambert shows what independent podcast journalism can achieve with persistence and careful reporting.
Hosted by Matthew Shaer & Eric Benson
Each season investigates a different case with deep reporting and narrative craft from The Atlantic.
Suspect brings magazine-quality reporting to the true crime format — high bar for production values.
Hosted by Ashley Flowers & Brit Prawat
Weekly true crime episodes with a devoted fanbase. Accessible, consistent, and highly produced.
Crime Junkie shows how consistency and audience relationship building drives true crime success.
Hosted by Paul Holes & Billy Jensen
A cold case investigator and a journalist team up to revisit unsolved cases. Expertise meets storytelling.
Holes and Jensen demonstrate how professional credentials add authority to true crime narration.
GRP 194-Ignorance is Bold and Knowledge Reserved: A Discussion with CIA Analyst Sarah Adams
Tell investigative stories with Hilite
Record interviews, edit by transcript, and publish your show. Free to start.
